To measure a removable throw pillow cover, take out the insert, turn the cover inside out, and lay it flat. Measure between the stitched seams in both directions without stretching the fabric. Use those dimensions, together with the cover maker’s insert recommendation, to choose a replacement.
A pillow that looks about 18 inches wide on the sofa may have a different labeled size. Once filled, its curved sides tuck away from the front view. Measuring the empty cover removes that uncertainty and gives you something useful to compare with a product listing.
Find the seams that define the cover
Open the zipper or envelope closure and remove the insert gently. If the cover has a care label or size tag, photograph it before turning the fabric inside out. Keep the original insert’s tag too, even if the filling has gone flat.
Spread the empty cover on a table. Smooth folds with your hands, but leave the fabric relaxed. Find the stitching that joins the front and back panels. On a cover with piping, the outer cord is not the measuring boundary. A flange or decorative border can also extend beyond the part that holds the insert.
The pillow maker Arianna Belle demonstrates measuring an empty, inside-out cover between its seams. That method helps you avoid treating the outside silhouette as the usable cover size.
Record width and height separately
Place a ruler or flexible tape straight across the flattened cover, with its zero mark at one side seam. Read the opposite seam, then repeat in the other direction. Keep the tape straight rather than laying it diagonally or wrapping it around the fabric.
Write down both measurements and the units. For a rectangular lumbar pillow, a note such as “12 inches high × 20 inches wide, empty cover, seam to seam” is clearer than “small rectangle.” For a square, measure both directions anyway; wear, laundering, or construction can leave them slightly different.
Check a surprising reading once more with the seams fully opened out. If a label says 20 inches but you repeatedly measure 19 inches, retain both numbers. Don’t pull the fabric to make it match the tag. Ask the seller whether its labeled size describes the finished cover, a nominal size, or its intended insert.
Choose fullness using the maker’s guidance
The measured cover size and the insert size are related, but they are not automatically identical. SNdsigns explains that a slightly larger insert can add fullness, while the fill and loft affect the result. It does not prescribe one size difference for every combination.
That is why “always add two inches” is an unreliable ordering rule. A dense insert, a delicate cover, and a narrow zipper opening behave differently from a soft insert in a sturdy, generously opening cover. Start with the cover’s recommendation, then check the specific insert’s compatibility advice.
For example, suppose an empty cover measures 18 × 18 inches and its maker recommends a 20 × 20-inch insert of a specified fill. That recommendation means selecting that listed insert size. It does not mean stretching the cover until it measures 20 inches, or adding another two inches to the recommended insert. This is an ordering example, not a universal size chart.
If the cover maker is unknown, send the insert seller your actual measurements, the closure type, and a photograph. Mention whether you want a softer pillow or a fuller decorative shape. A clear answer about that combination is more useful than guessing from the insert’s apparent width in a photograph.
Keep unusual shapes and closures in mind
A boxed cushion has a side panel that adds depth. A round cover has a diameter rather than square width and height. Bolsters and shaped pillows need their own dimensions. Don’t apply a square throw-pillow rule to these designs; use the maker’s measurement diagram or ask for help.
A sewn-shut pillow also needs a different approach. Do not cut it open merely to follow the removable-cover method. Look for its label, original order, or maker’s identification first. If you plan to replace the cover through a sewing professional, let that person specify the measurements needed.
Check the fit without straining the fabric
When the new insert arrives, compare its label with the item ordered before removing packaging or tags that affect returns. Follow any supplied expansion instructions. Fold or compress the insert gently as its maker permits, work it through the opening, and ease the corners into place.
The closure should fasten without a hard pull, distorted seams, or a bowed zipper. If it will not close comfortably, stop and check the recommended pairing. Forcing the zipper can damage a cover that would otherwise remain usable. Keep the measurement note and the successful insert’s product details so the next replacement is straightforward.

