Colorful fruit cocktail popsicles with diced fruit served on ice beside fresh strawberries and orange slices.

Easy Canned Fruit Cocktail Popsicles

Canned fruit cocktail makes surprisingly good homemade popsicles. Drain most of the liquid, lightly mash some of the fruit, add just enough reserved syrup or juice to loosen the mixture, and freeze it in molds.

Lightly mashing the fruit works especially well because it leaves recognizable pieces while creating enough of a base to hold the pop together. A little lemon juice brightens the flavor, and yogurt is an optional addition if you prefer a creamier pop.

Canned Fruit Cocktail Popsicles Recipe

Yield: About 4 to 6 popsicles, depending on mold size
Prep time: 10 minutes
Freezing time: 4 to 6 hours
Total time: About 4 hours 10 minutes, plus additional freezing if needed
Course: Dessert
Method: No-cook, frozen

Equipment

  • Fine-mesh strainer or colander
  • Medium bowl
  • Fork or potato masher
  • Knife and cutting board, if the fruit pieces are large
  • Popsicle molds and sticks

Small paper cups can replace popsicle molds.

Ingredients

  • 1 can (about 15 ounces/425 grams) fruit cocktail packed in light syrup or juice
  • 2 tablespoons (30 milliliters) reserved canning liquid, plus a little more if needed
  • 1 teaspoon (5 milliliters) lemon juice
  • 2 tablespoons (30 milliliters) plain or vanilla yogurt, optional

If the fruit is packed in juice rather than syrup and you prefer a slightly softer, sweeter pop, you can add 1 teaspoon sugar along with the reserved juice.

How to Make Canned Fruit Cocktail Popsicles

Drain the fruit cocktail over a bowl, saving some of the liquid.

Check the size of the fruit pieces. Chop large pieces of peach, pear, pineapple, or grape into smaller bites. Frozen fruit becomes quite firm, so smaller pieces are easier to eat from a popsicle.

Place the drained fruit in a bowl. Mash roughly half of it with a fork, leaving the rest in small pieces.

Stir in 2 tablespoons of the reserved syrup or juice and the lemon juice. Add the yogurt, if using. The mixture should be moist enough to spoon easily into the molds but should still contain plenty of fruit.

Taste the mixture before freezing. If fruit packed in juice tastes too tart or bland, add 1 teaspoon sugar. Fruit packed in syrup usually needs no additional sweetener.

Spoon the mixture into the molds, distributing the fruit evenly. Leave a little room at the top for expansion.

Insert the sticks according to the mold instructions and freeze until solid, usually 4 to 6 hours. Larger molds may need longer. Overnight freezing is fine.

To unmold, hold the outside of the mold under lukewarm water for a few seconds. Pull gently rather than twisting the stick.

Light Syrup or Juice: Which Works Better?

Either type of canned fruit cocktail can be used, but the packing liquid changes the finished texture.

Fruit cocktailHow to use it
Packed in heavy syrupDrain thoroughly and use only a small amount of syrup
Packed in light syrupA good choice for the basic recipe; start with 2 tablespoons
Packed in fruit juiceUse the juice, but expect a somewhat firmer pop
No-sugar-added fruitAdd yogurt or a small amount of sugar if the mixture freezes harder than you prefer

Sugar affects the way water freezes, which is one reason syrup-packed fruit can produce a less icy homemade pop. There is no need to pour the entire can of syrup into the molds. Too much liquid dilutes the fruit and can allow the pieces to settle.

Start with a couple of tablespoons and add more only if the mixture seems too thick to fill the molds.

Why Lightly Mashing the Fruit Works Well

You can freeze the fruit cocktail whole, mash it, or puree it, but lightly mashing about half gives these popsicles a useful middle ground.

Whole pieces suspended in a thin liquid tend to settle and can be awkward to bite once frozen. A completely pureed mixture loses the recognizable fruit cocktail texture.

Mashing some of the fruit thickens the mixture naturally while leaving small pieces throughout the pop.

If you prefer a smooth ice pop, briefly pulse the entire mixture in a blender. Stop when the fruit is broken down rather than blending it into a thin juice.

How to Keep the Fruit From Settling

Fruit settles most easily when there is a large amount of thin liquid in the mold.

Draining the fruit and mashing part of it usually solves most of the problem. Spoon some fruit into each mold as you fill it instead of pouring the entire mixture from a pitcher.

For especially large molds, fill them halfway and freeze until the mixture begins to become slushy. Add the remaining mixture and continue freezing. This takes longer but helps distribute chunky fruit from top to bottom.

Three Easy Variations

Creamy Fruit Cocktail Popsicles

Increase the yogurt to 1/4 cup (60 milliliters). Use only enough reserved syrup or juice to make the mixture easy to spoon into the molds.

Vanilla yogurt makes a sweeter dessert-style pop. Plain yogurt leaves more of the canned fruit flavor intact.

Pineapple-Coconut Fruit Pops

Replace the yogurt with 2 tablespoons (30 milliliters) canned coconut milk and replace some or all of the reserved canning liquid with pineapple juice.

Add a spoonful of finely chopped canned pineapple if you have some open.

Lemon-Lime Fruit Pops

Use 1 teaspoon lemon or lime juice and, if desired, a small amount of finely grated citrus zest.

Taste before adding extra juice. Too much additional liquid can dilute the fruit mixture and make the finished pops more icy.

Making a Half-Can Batch

A half batch is useful when you have only a few molds or are cooking for one or two people.

Use approximately:

  • 1/2 can fruit cocktail
  • 1 tablespoon (15 milliliters) reserved syrup or juice
  • 1/2 teaspoon lemon juice
  • 1 tablespoon (15 milliliters) yogurt, optional

Mash part of the fruit and prepare it in the same way as the full recipe.

Transfer the unused fruit and liquid from the opened can to a covered container and refrigerate it rather than storing it in the opened can. Use it according to the storage directions on the package.

No Popsicle Molds? Use Paper Cups

Small paper cups work well for homemade popsicles.

Fill each cup with the fruit mixture and place the cups upright in the freezer. If the sticks will not remain centered, freeze the cups until the mixture is slushy enough to support them, then insert the sticks and return the cups to the freezer.

Peel the paper cup away when ready to eat.

This method is also handy for making only two or three popsicles without filling an entire mold set.

Troubleshooting Canned Fruit Popsicles

The popsicles are too hard

Fruit packed in juice or water generally makes a firmer pop than fruit packed in syrup.

Next time, use a little reserved syrup, add a teaspoon of sugar, or include a small amount of yogurt. Avoid adding extra water simply to increase the volume.

Letting a very firm pop stand at room temperature for a minute or two before eating can also make it easier to bite.

The fruit collected at one end

The mixture was probably too thin or the fruit pieces were too large.

Drain more of the liquid, chop the fruit smaller, and mash part of the fruit before filling the molds.

The flavor seems dull after freezing

Cold temperatures can make flavors seem less pronounced. A teaspoon of lemon or lime juice usually gives canned fruit a fresher taste without making the pops noticeably sour.

Taste the mixture before freezing and make small adjustments rather than adding large amounts of juice.

The popsicle will not come out of the mold

Run only the outside of the mold under lukewarm water for several seconds.

Do not pull hard on the stick. If the pop still resists, warm the mold for another few seconds and try again.

Storing Homemade Fruit Popsicles

Once the popsicles are completely frozen, they can stay in their molds or be transferred to a covered freezer container or freezer bag. If several pops are stored together, separate them with parchment or wax paper if they stick.

Keep the freezer at 0°F (-18°C) or below. Freezing prevents microbial growth while food remains frozen, although quality gradually declines during freezer storage.

If you use yogurt, keep the mixture refrigerated until you are ready to fill and freeze the molds.

For the best texture, lightly mash the fruit and keep just enough of the canned syrup or juice to bind the mixture. Freeze the pops until solid, then give a very hard pop a minute or two to soften slightly before eating.


Discover more from Life Happens!

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.