Two slices of pie side by side, with dense golden chess pie on the left and pale, smooth buttermilk custard on the right.

Chess pie usually has a dense, buttery filling with a pronounced sweetness. Buttermilk pie has a softer custard and a tang you can taste through the sugar. Both are Southern favorites made with eggs, butter, and sugar in a single pastry crust. To tell them apart, look at what goes into the filling.

How the fillings compare

FeatureChess pieButtermilk pie
Main ingredientsEggs, sugar, butter, and often a little cornmealEggs, sugar, butter, and cultured buttermilk
What gives it bodyEggs with a little cornmeal, flour, or both, depending on the recipeEggs with a little flour in many traditional versions
FlavorUsually sweeter and more buttery, sometimes with a little vinegar or lemonSweet with a more distinct dairy tang, often flavored with vanilla
TextureDense and sliceable, with a thin, sometimes crackly topSoft, smooth custard with a lightly browned top

In chess pie, a spoonful of fine cornmeal adds body and can leave a faint graininess or a delicate crust on top. A splash of vinegar or lemon can take the edge off the sweetness. Cornmeal is a clue, though recipes vary. King Arthur Baking’s lemon chess pie, for example, combines cornmeal with cornstarch and gets its sharpness from lemon.

Cultured buttermilk supplies both the liquid and the tang in a buttermilk pie. The custard can still be rich, especially with melted butter. A traditional flour-thickened buttermilk pie shows how simple the filling can be. Lemon zest or nutmeg can change the flavor without changing the style of the pie.

Where buttermilk chess pie fits

Buttermilk chess pie combines the tang of cultured buttermilk with the texture of chess pie. In one buttermilk chess pie, buttermilk supplies the tang, and finely ground cornmeal helps give the filling its chess pie texture. A browned or crackly top alone tells you little because either pie can brown. If a recipe carries both names, read the ingredient list to see whether it will bake up dense and sweet or closer to a soft custard.

When to take either pie out of the oven

Start checking at the early end of the recipe’s baking window. The outside of the filling should be set and the center should move slightly as a single patch when you nudge the pie plate. If the center sloshes, keep baking. A loose ring of foil can shield the crust if the edges darken before the middle sets.

Let the pie settle on a rack, then refrigerate it within two hours of baking and chill before slicing. The custard firms as it cools. Keep it covered in the refrigerator and use it within three to four days. FoodSafety.gov’s cold storage chart gives the refrigerator window for custard pies.

Which pie should you bake?

Choose chess pie if you want a sweeter dessert with a firm filling that holds a slender wedge. Choose buttermilk pie if you want the tang and softer texture of a custard, especially after a rich meal. For a dessert tray, the fillings also work in brown sugar chess pie bars or vanilla-nutmeg buttermilk pie bars.


Discover more from Life Happens!

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.